Not All Dermal Fillers Are Created Equal: The Science Explained
THE FORMULA / AESTHETIC SCIENCE
By Chloe Maher | BSc Chemistry

When we talk about dermal filler, it's easy to focus on the amount being injected: 0.5ml, 1ml, or perhaps a little more.
But there's something equally important that isn't always discussed: the science behind the filler itself.
Two products may contain the same core ingredient, hyaluronic acid, yet behave differently once injected. Their texture, firmness, elasticity and ability to integrate with surrounding tissue can vary considerably.
So why does this happen?
The answer lies in chemistry.
First, what actually is hyaluronic acid?
Hyaluronic acid (HA) is a naturally occurring molecule found throughout the human body, including in our skin and connective tissues.
It's a type of glycosaminoglycan: a long chain of repeating sugar-based units. One of its defining characteristics is its ability to interact with water, contributing to tissue hydration and the properties of the extracellular matrix.
In aesthetic medicine, specially formulated HA gels can be used to add volume, alter facial contours or soften the appearance of certain lines.
However, the hyaluronic acid found naturally in our tissues isn't identical in structure or behaviour to the stabilised gels used in most HA dermal fillers.
This is where formulation chemistry becomes particularly interesting.
The chemistry of crosslinking
If we were to inject unmodified hyaluronic acid, it would generally be broken down and cleared relatively quickly.
To create longer-lasting dermal filler gels, manufacturers commonly use a process called crosslinking.
Crosslinking introduces connections between HA chains, creating a three-dimensional network that changes how the material behaves.
One commonly used crosslinking agent is BDDE (1,4-butanediol diglycidyl ether).
The way a filler is manufactured, including its crosslinking process, HA concentration and gel structure, influences its physical properties.
Importantly, the presence of BDDE in manufacturing does not automatically mean a product contains unsafe levels of residual BDDE. Residual crosslinking agent, product purification and biocompatibility all require appropriate testing.
Nor does a greater degree of crosslinking automatically mean a better filler.
Different formulations are designed with different properties and purposes in mind.
Understanding filler rheology
Now for one of my favourite areas of filler science: rheology.
Rheology is the study of how materials flow and deform when forces are applied to them.
Think about the difference between honey, jelly and a firm gel. All three can change shape, but they behave very differently when squeezed, stretched or moved.
Dermal fillers are no exception. Three important concepts help explain these differences.
01 / Elasticity — G′
The elastic modulus, known as G′ (pronounced G prime), describes the elastic component of a material's response to deformation.
In simple terms, it helps us understand how a gel resists changes in shape.
A filler with a relatively high G′ may be more resistant to deformation under particular testing conditions than one with a lower G′.
However, G′ alone does not tell us whether a product is suitable for a specific facial area.
02 / Viscosity
Viscosity describes resistance to flow.
Alongside other rheological properties, it influences how a gel behaves when force is applied, including during injection.
It's one reason two HA fillers can feel and handle differently, even when their ingredient lists look similar.
03 / Cohesivity
Cohesivity describes how strongly a gel's components hold together.
This can influence how a filler maintains its structure or deforms within tissues.
Like elasticity, cohesivity cannot be considered in isolation. Its measurement also depends on the testing method used.
The important takeaway? No single rheological measurement can tell us everything about a filler's performance.
Why does this matter for different treatment areas?
Different facial areas have different anatomical structures, movement patterns and treatment objectives.
For example, a product chosen for subtle lip enhancement may require different characteristics from one selected for structural support in another area of the face.
The intended outcome, tissue characteristics, treatment depth, product-specific instructions and individual anatomy all influence treatment planning.
This is why choosing a filler should involve more than simply selecting a familiar brand or deciding how many millilitres to use.
It's also why two practitioners may use different HA products for different indications.
The aim isn't to find the universally “best” filler. It's to understand which product characteristics may be appropriate for a particular treatment, supported by clinical evidence, product guidance and a thorough assessment.
Does more expensive mean better?
Not necessarily.
A higher price does not automatically establish that a filler is safer, more suitable or capable of producing a better outcome.
Equally, a lower price is not, by itself, proof of poor quality.
When evaluating a dermal filler, relevant considerations include its regulatory status, clinical evidence, manufacturer quality controls, intended use and documented safety profile.
The skill, training and judgement of the practitioner also matter.
And regardless of product choice, injectable treatments carry risks. These include swelling, bruising, infection, nodules and, rarely, serious vascular complications such as tissue injury or visual loss.
A high-quality product does not eliminate those risks.
The BY CHLOE perspective
My background in Chemistry has shaped the way I approach aesthetic products.
I'm fascinated by the relationship between molecular structure, material properties and the way formulations are designed for different applications.
But scientific knowledge is only one part of thoughtful aesthetic practice.
It must sit alongside appropriate practical training, understanding of anatomy, individual assessment, informed consent and clear communication about risks and limitations.
At BY CHLOE, my aim is to bring that scientific curiosity into the treatment experience, while recognising that every person is individual.
Because when it comes to aesthetics, understanding what's inside the syringe matters just as much as understanding the person receiving treatment.
Considering dermal filler?
Explore our dermal filler treatments or arrange a consultation to discuss your concerns, expectations and suitability.
Further reading
The Rheology and Physicochemical Characteristics of Hyaluronic Acid Fillers: Their Clinical Implications — Peer-reviewed review
Rheologic and Physicochemical Characteristics of Hyaluronic Acid Fillers — Peer-reviewed review
Dermal Fillers (Soft Tissue Fillers) — US FDA safety information

Comments